Reliance Industries Ltd. (RIL) rose after India’s federal auditor reversed its view of the oil producer and asked the government to resolve price disputes and allow some exploration cost recoveries.
The shares rose 0.3 percent to 991.60 rupees at the close in Mumbai after surging as much as 2.9 percent. The stock has gained 11 percent this year, lagging behind the benchmark S&P BSE Sensex (SENSEX)’s 36 percent gain, as output from its biggest gas field KG-D6 continues to decline.
The Comptroller & Auditor General of India submitted a report to lawmakers today asking the oil ministry to approve exploration and production budgets on time, which it had failed to do every year from 2008 to 2012. It also said Reliance and its partners should be allowed to recover some of the costs incurred to drill wells in the KG-D6 block, a proposal rejected by the government.
The auditor’s “indication shows Reliance has done things according to its contract,” Dhaval Joshi, a Mumbai-based oil and gas analyst with Emkay Global Financial Services Pvt., said by phone. “A company which has spent so much in that block will have enough evidence to prove it’s right.”
Reliance owns 60 percent of the KG-D6 block, BP Plc 30 percent and Calgary-based Niko Resources Ltd. (NKO) 10 percent.
No Recovery
Reliance has not been allowed to recover $2.38 billion of expenses as of March 31, 2014, Oil Minister Dharmendra Pradhan said in parliament this week. It was penalized because gas output from KG-D6 was less than planned.
In 2011, the auditor had written in a report that the government’s share of profit from the KG-D6 deposit may have been curtailed because Reliance incurred higher operating costs in awarding contracts. It said Reliance placed some orders after getting single bids and revised the scope and specifications of contracts.
“We could not derive assurance as to the reasonableness of costs incurred” on the contracts awarded in the two years ended March 2008, the auditor said in the report submitted in parliament on Sept. 8, 2011.
The payments may have “adverse implications” for the recovery of exploration costs and the government’s share of profit from the field, it said, without quantifying the loss.
Reliance started arbitration against the government’s order in November 2011.
‘National Interest’
Producers in India are allowed to recover investments in their fields from the sale of oil and gas. Reliance and its partners spent $10.44 billion on the block off the nation’s east coast until March 2013 and have recovered $9.29 billion, according to today’s report.
Today’s report also recommended that “keeping in mind the national interest and energy security” Reliance and its partners be allowed to recover some of the $427.03 million they spent to drill 14 other wells in the block. Some of these wells resulted in gas discoveries. Of this amount, $119.99 million shouldn’t be allowed to be recovered, the auditor said.
The federal auditor also wants the oil ministry to resolve disputes on estimates on gas reserves in the block and take steps to raise output. The auditor can only recommend and doesn’t have any power to form policy.
“If the government takes a cue from this and sorts out all contract issues, than it’ll only be good for the companies and the country,” Joshi said.
Falling Output
Gas production from the KG-D6 block has been falling since August 2010 after it started output in April of the previous year and increased it to about 60 million cubic meters a day. Reliance has said output is dropping because the field is more difficult to produce from than it initially estimated. The oil ministry says Reliance has drilled enough wells.
Production from the block fell 57 percent to 40.6 billion cubic feet in the quarter ended Sept. 30 from a year earlier, Reliance said Oct. 13.
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi came to power in May, ending 10 years of Congress party rule. He has promised to revive the economy from the slowest pace of growth in almost a decade and create jobs. For this to happen, he needs to ensure fuel supplies, including gas, consumed primarily by power and fertilizer plants and used in homes for cooking.
Source: Bloomberg
The shares rose 0.3 percent to 991.60 rupees at the close in Mumbai after surging as much as 2.9 percent. The stock has gained 11 percent this year, lagging behind the benchmark S&P BSE Sensex (SENSEX)’s 36 percent gain, as output from its biggest gas field KG-D6 continues to decline.
The Comptroller & Auditor General of India submitted a report to lawmakers today asking the oil ministry to approve exploration and production budgets on time, which it had failed to do every year from 2008 to 2012. It also said Reliance and its partners should be allowed to recover some of the costs incurred to drill wells in the KG-D6 block, a proposal rejected by the government.
The auditor’s “indication shows Reliance has done things according to its contract,” Dhaval Joshi, a Mumbai-based oil and gas analyst with Emkay Global Financial Services Pvt., said by phone. “A company which has spent so much in that block will have enough evidence to prove it’s right.”
Reliance owns 60 percent of the KG-D6 block, BP Plc 30 percent and Calgary-based Niko Resources Ltd. (NKO) 10 percent.
No Recovery
Reliance has not been allowed to recover $2.38 billion of expenses as of March 31, 2014, Oil Minister Dharmendra Pradhan said in parliament this week. It was penalized because gas output from KG-D6 was less than planned.
In 2011, the auditor had written in a report that the government’s share of profit from the KG-D6 deposit may have been curtailed because Reliance incurred higher operating costs in awarding contracts. It said Reliance placed some orders after getting single bids and revised the scope and specifications of contracts.
“We could not derive assurance as to the reasonableness of costs incurred” on the contracts awarded in the two years ended March 2008, the auditor said in the report submitted in parliament on Sept. 8, 2011.
The payments may have “adverse implications” for the recovery of exploration costs and the government’s share of profit from the field, it said, without quantifying the loss.
Reliance started arbitration against the government’s order in November 2011.
‘National Interest’
Producers in India are allowed to recover investments in their fields from the sale of oil and gas. Reliance and its partners spent $10.44 billion on the block off the nation’s east coast until March 2013 and have recovered $9.29 billion, according to today’s report.
Today’s report also recommended that “keeping in mind the national interest and energy security” Reliance and its partners be allowed to recover some of the $427.03 million they spent to drill 14 other wells in the block. Some of these wells resulted in gas discoveries. Of this amount, $119.99 million shouldn’t be allowed to be recovered, the auditor said.
The federal auditor also wants the oil ministry to resolve disputes on estimates on gas reserves in the block and take steps to raise output. The auditor can only recommend and doesn’t have any power to form policy.
“If the government takes a cue from this and sorts out all contract issues, than it’ll only be good for the companies and the country,” Joshi said.
Falling Output
Gas production from the KG-D6 block has been falling since August 2010 after it started output in April of the previous year and increased it to about 60 million cubic meters a day. Reliance has said output is dropping because the field is more difficult to produce from than it initially estimated. The oil ministry says Reliance has drilled enough wells.
Production from the block fell 57 percent to 40.6 billion cubic feet in the quarter ended Sept. 30 from a year earlier, Reliance said Oct. 13.
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi came to power in May, ending 10 years of Congress party rule. He has promised to revive the economy from the slowest pace of growth in almost a decade and create jobs. For this to happen, he needs to ensure fuel supplies, including gas, consumed primarily by power and fertilizer plants and used in homes for cooking.
Source: Bloomberg